US Trade Representative Froman: “The cynical repetition of positions designed to produce deadlock”

A response from U.S. researcher Timothy A. Wise, Tufts University

Nairobi contacts: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it., 073-297-6576

Today, US Trade Representative Michael Froman delivered his plenary statement to the trade ministers gathered in Nairobi for the World Trade Organization’s tenth ministerial conference. His statement, which calls for the abandonment of the Doha Development Round in favor of negotiations on new issues of more strategic interest to the United States, deserve a response from a countryman.

Mr. Froman calls on trade representatives “to move beyond the cynical repetition of positions designed to produce deadlock.” Yet this is precisely what Mr. Froman has come to Nairobi to repeat: U.S. positions designed to produce deadlock.

He decries the lack of progress in the last 15 years of Doha negotiations, yet he fails to acknowledge that the United States has been, and remains, the principal reason for that failure. Since 2008, when negotiations broke down, the U.S. has refused to continue negotiating on the key issues central to the development agenda – reducing agricultural subsidies, allowing developing countries special protection measures for agriculture, eliminating export subsidies and credits, and a host of other issues.

Those issues remain critical to developing countries, and U.S. intransigence in addressing those concerns is the main reason Doha has stagnated. In addition, the U.S. has introduced new issues to create further obstacles to progress, such as its objection to India’s ambitious and laudable public stockholding program to provide food security to fully two-thirds of its people.

The draft declaration on agriculture in Nairobi offers no progress on resolving this issue, despite the explicit commitment in Bali and later in Geneva to find a permanent solution that can allow India and other countries to pursue such programs.

That is not the only developing country issue left unaddressed. The declaration offers nothing to developing countries to allow them to protect sensitive sectors from unfair or sudden import surges, the Special Safeguard Mechanism. It offers no meaningful cuts in U.S. export credits, which have favored U.S. exporters to Africa with some $1.25 billion in credits over the last six years.

Perhaps most notably, the declaration makes no mention of the key issue in the Doha Round: reductions in rich country agricultural subsidies and supports. With crop prices low and a new Farm Bill authorizing rising levels of support to U.S. farmers and exporters, this omission is a direct blow to those developing countries which see their farmers and export prospects harmed by underpriced U.S. exports.

Nor does Mr. Froman mention cotton subsidies, an issue which the United States and the WTO membership committed to address “expeditiously” ten long years ago in Hong Kong. The issue remains unresolved, and the draft agriculture text fails to offer anything to Africa’s C-4 cotton producing countries, which have millions of poor farmers desperately in need of relief.

Instead, the U.S. Farm Bill promises further price suppression. According to a recent study, cotton subsidies could total $1.5 million, increasing U.S. exports 29% and suppressing prices by 7%. All cotton producers in the rest of the world will suffer an estimated $3.3 billion in annual losses, with India projected to lose $800 million per year.

The C-4 countries as a group stand to lose $80 million a year in reduced income, a huge blow to struggling farmers in low-income countries.

Mr. Froman touts the ways U.S. policy has moved forward beyond Doha. He says the United States extended the African Growth and Opportunity Act by a decade, “the longest extension in that program’s history.” That limited extension of trade preferences to African countries last year provided a paltry $264,000 in benefits to the C-4 countries. The projected losses from U.S. cotton dumping are 300 times greater.

Mr. Froman concludes that with a new approach that abandons the development round while taking up issues of investment, procurement, and other matters of priority to the United States, “we can ensure that global trade will drive development and prosperity as strongly this century as it did in the last.”

The U.S. Trade Representative seems to have conveniently forgotten that the Doha Development Round he wants to sweep aside was a direct response to the fact that global trade rules in the last century failed to drive development and prosperity, at least for many developing countries.

As a U.S. researcher long engaged with the issues of concern to developing countries, I find Mr. Froman’s approach shameful. Multilateralism demands engagement and compromise, particularly in a “development round” designed to address past inequities. Mr. Froman is unfortunately offering nothing more than “the cynical repetition of positions designed to produce deadlock.” The latest in a steady stream of U.S. hypocrisy.

Timothy A. Wise is Policy Research Director at Tufts University’s Global Development and Environment Institute.

Last modified onFriday, 18 December 2015 13:32


  • James


    Comment Link Friday, 04 May 2018 10:22

    Excellent blog here! Also your web site loads up very fast! What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  • StevenaSloge


    Comment Link Monday, 02 April 2018 22:28

    my husband hides viagra can viagra be taken with coumadin generic viagra review

  • StevenaSloge


    Comment Link Monday, 02 April 2018 21:36

    what to say to your dr. to get viagra where to buy viagra in windsor ontario generic viagra review

  • StevenaSloge


    Comment Link Monday, 02 April 2018 21:10

    brand viagra 50 mg when will the generic viagra be available generic viagra online

  • loxgauth


    Comment Link Monday, 02 April 2018 20:40

    Now playing: Bleeding and spotting during pregnancyGestational diabetesGestational hypertension and preeclampsiaPregnancy: The overweight or obese womanSeasonal flu and pregnancy brightcove. cialis daily buy cialis tadalafil tablets - cialis online American Cancer Society, Lymphoma, accessed 23 May 2015. OK’

  • StevenaSloge


    Comment Link Monday, 02 April 2018 20:17

    viagra and atenolol interaction what happens to viagra when it expires buy generic viagra

  • OscarAmism


    Comment Link Monday, 02 April 2018 19:47

    order viagra thailand
    viagra tablet
    viagra women sale australia
    viagra pills 100 mg
    cheap herbal viagra online
    viagra for sale uk only
    cheap viagra for sale in the uk
    viagra for sale uk
    buy viagra bali

  • StevenaSloge


    Comment Link Monday, 02 April 2018 18:04

    kan ik viagra bij de apotheek kopen user reviews of viagra buy generic viagra

  • StevenaSloge


    Comment Link Monday, 02 April 2018 17:35

    how long viagra effect lasts viagra is good for health buy generic viagra

  • Myronavaiz


    Comment Link Monday, 02 April 2018 11:47 accutane online canada pharmacy safe online pharmacy canada canada pharmacy online online pharmacy canada viagra

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated. HTML code is not allowed.

back to top