Governments must now pursue trade multilateralism piece by piece
After a death scene so drawn-out it would have done credit to a Victorian melodrama, the curtain has finally come down on one of the longest-running farces in global policymaking. The so-called Doha round, the programme of multilateral trade talks that started in 2001, was last week declared dead by World Trade Organisation members after nearly a decade spent comatose.
The admission that Doha is no more is welcome: the talks were wasting a lot of breath, time, energy and air miles. But to preserve the negotiating function of the WTO, member governments need to pursue other ways of doing business that preserve the multilateral approach as far as possible while having a fighting chance of actually producing a deal.
Doha was launched in 2001, two months after the September 11 attacks, with much rhetoric about gestures of global unity but too little support from businesses to keep it going. It was also oversold as a “development round”, with the aim of helping poorer countries trade their way out of poverty, with a particular focus on agriculture.
Three problems rapidly became evident. One, behind the mask of solidarity between developing countries lay deep divisions, for example between agricultural net importers and exporters, preventing constructive proposals for liberalisation. Two, countries such as China transformed beyond recognition during the round, becoming global export powerhouses yet continuing to plead developing country status. Three, the US in particular proved to be largely spineless in taking on its own farm lobby, which demanded improbable amounts of market access abroad in return for subsidy cuts at home.
Doha in effect died when a ministerial meeting failed in 2008. While it continued for anotherr seven years on life support, governments, particularly the US, have pushed ahead with bilateral or regional deals. These agreements, the most prominent of which is the Trans-Pacific Partnership, are a weak substitute for multilateral deals, not least because they are often one-sided agreements written by the strongest signatory.
A better approach would be plurilateral pacts among a group of governments, expanding to more countries after their creation and eventually being multilateralised under WTO rules. Some such deals — an agreement on government procurement and another on information technology goods — are already in place.
In the months after the failure of the 2008 ministerial meeting, a group of countries moved ahead with plurilateral talks on services trade liberalisation outside the aegis of the WTO. A successful conclusion of this services deal, and then expanding it and bringing it within the existing WTO services agreement, would send a strong signal that a broad-based negotiating function is still in place.
The WTO certainly has it faults: the need to reach consensus among all countries is inimical to swift, decisive policymaking. But it remains the best forum in which to set or at least administer many of the rules of world trade. Its dispute settlement function, in which panels of independent arbiters rule on cases brought by governments, still has credibility.
Having failed to save Doha in the WTO, its members must now save the WTO from Doha. The time and energy that was poured into a failing project can now be redirected into smaller deals that can still bolster the credibility of the institution and its members.
Doha is dead. Its passing should not be mourned. It opens up the space for trade multilateralism to be reborn.
Evan Ottenfeld | Legislative Assistant and Scheduler
Public Citizen's Global Trade Watch
215 Pennsylvania Ave SE, Washington, DC 20003
Latest from SEATINI Kenya
- Latest EGA Negotiations To Focus On Final List, Phase outs, 'Critical Mass'
- Some ICs plan "modern trade deals" at WTO Published in SUNS #8210 dated 30 March 2016
- 54th Session of the Commission for Social Development
- China, Japan Vie For Permanent Appellate Body Seat At WTO
- Nairobi Rules On Article 9.4 Subsidies, Export Credits May Be Enforceable
JerryshornComment Link Friday, 17 November 2017 20:45
order cialis to canada
cialis without a doctor's prescription
cialis fake pills
cialis without prescription
cialis liquid for sale
JoeFlamiComment Link Thursday, 16 November 2017 23:41
buy an essay paper buy essay online buy essay online help writing college essays
SamuelunlabComment Link Wednesday, 15 November 2017 16:59
liquid cialis for sale
can you buy cialis over counter spain
cheap kamagra cialis
MichaelRorComment Link Wednesday, 15 November 2017 15:03
cialis sale london
cialis without a doctor's prescription
buy cialis south africa
buy cialis online eu
RodneyLerComment Link Wednesday, 15 November 2017 02:43
order brand name cialis
what color are cialis pills
what does cialis pills look like
EnriquekesComment Link Tuesday, 14 November 2017 21:52
buy cialis new delhi
buy cialis viagra online
the cheapest generic cialis
WilliemusComment Link Tuesday, 14 November 2017 17:12
viagra cialis buy uk
buy cialis online canadian pharmacy
buy cialis super active
JamesFlamiComment Link Tuesday, 14 November 2017 17:10
writing a paper paper writing ontario math homework help writing a paper adult cam free live sex chats adult webcam live webcams sex free sex video chat adult video chat free adult video chat adult webcam sites college essay argument essays college essays homework help ontario
YapparovaTotComment Link Tuesday, 14 November 2017 16:51
best viagra in bangladesh
http://viagraonline100mgs.com/ - generic viagra online
viagra prix acheter
DavidjibComment Link Tuesday, 14 November 2017 15:38
cialis buy australia
can cialis pills be split