G-33 Pushes SSM, Stockholding Outcomes; Gaps Persist At Ag Committee

NAIROBI, Kenya -- On the eve of the 10th World Trade Organization ministerial here, the G-33 has doubled down on its push for outcomes on public stockholding and a special safeguard mechanism (SSM), which are non-starters for agricultural exporting countries, further illustrating the persistent and deep divisions among members on key issues.

The G-33, a group of developing countries with sensitivities to greater agricultural imports, in a ministerial communique adopted Monday (Dec. 14) reiterated that it sees outcomes on the SSM and public stockholding for food security purposes as critical elements of a Nairobi package.

"[T]he G-33 is making its utmost efforts through its active engagement and proposals on SSM, as part of its quest for an effective tool agreeable for all Members in the context of achieving meaningful, development-centered balanced and credible deliverables of MC10," the communique said.

"The G-33 also remains committed to implement the Bali Ministerial Decision of 7 December 2013 on Public Stockholding for Food Security Purposes by putting forward a proposal on this issue with a view to engage constructively to negotiate and make all concerted efforts to agree and adopt a permanent solution by December 2015 as mandated by the General Council Decision, dated 27 November 2014," it continued.

In November 2014, members agreed to "make all concerted efforts" to find a solution on public stockholding by the end of 2015. But agricultural exporters including the U.S., Brazil and Argentina have made clear that they are not willing to agree to an outcome on public stockholding without receiving reciprocal market access, an issue that is not even expected to be discussed this week.

The G-33 was among several groups of WTO members who held meetings here on Monday. At a meeting of the G-20 that followed, members were at a standstill over the public stockholding and SSM issues.

The G-20 is a group of developing countries that focus on agricultural issues. Those members that are a part of both groups -- including India and Indonesia -- reiterated their support for SSM and public stockholding, but were met with strong pushback from Brazil, Argentina, Paraguay and Uruguay.

Other groups meeting today include the Cairns Group; the African, Caribbean, and Pacific Group; and the group of least-developed countries (LDCs). After those meetings, the WTO's agriculture negotiating group held an informal meeting and discussed SSM, public stockholding and export competition.

The meeting was called to discuss what progress members had made during their smaller group meetings, but it appeared that no members had moved from their previously stated positions.

India has threatened to block a deal on export subsidies if there is no solution on public stockholding, but the U.S. does not believe a deal on public stockholding is possible this week because of the lack of progress in that area. It has also signaled that the G-33 proposal on public stockholding is disingenuous because it reiterates the same position it took prior to the 2013 Bali ministerial, which members were unable to agree to then.

Then, India led the charge in pushing for what would essentially be a permanent “peace clause” shielding public stockholding programs for food security from challenge under the WTO Agreement on Agriculture, even if they breach subsidy limits. It ultimately settled for a temporary peace clause that is to last until some kind of solution to this issue is found.

The G-33 ministerial communique also called for a "balanced" outcome on export competition that respects the principle of special and differential treatment for developing members.

"We reiterate the importance of maintaining special and differential treatment in the areas of export competition," the communique said. "Negotiations in this area should be conducted by taking into account the need for balanced, development-centered and credible outcomes in Nairobi."

This appears to be at odds with the U.S. demand that developing countries eventually be subject to all new disciplines reached under a deal on export competition.

Correction: A previous version of this story used an incorrect title when referring to the WTO's agriculture negotiating group.

  • Rate this item
    (0 votes)
  • Published in Updates
  • Read 2568 times


  • best casino online

    best casino online

    Comment Link Thursday, 14 December 2017 17:31

    casino slots
    online casino usa
    casino slots
    online casino real money

  • Thanhdax


    Comment Link Thursday, 14 December 2017 11:36

    viagra at a discount
    viagra without prescription
    precio del viagra generico
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    to buy viagra in uk
    viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland
    securetabs online viagra 100mg
    viagra no script
    which is cheaper viagra or cialis

  • Thomasspusy


    Comment Link Thursday, 14 December 2017 05:46

    safe buy viagra online uk
    viagra without prescription
    how to buy viagra in ireland
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    can you buy viagra in brazil
    viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland
    que precio tiene el viagra de 50 mg. en mexico
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    how to get viagra online

  • KennethshugH


    Comment Link Thursday, 14 December 2017 01:20

    generico do viagra e cialis
    viagra without prescription
    viagra 100mg preis
    viagra without prescription
    original viagra price
    viagra no prescription
    online viagra legal
    viagra without prescription
    sildenafil cheap

  • casino online

    casino online

    Comment Link Wednesday, 13 December 2017 23:31

    online casino real money
    best online casino
    free casino slot games
    online casinos

  • Thomasvor


    Comment Link Wednesday, 13 December 2017 22:38

    viagra online uk pfizer
    viagra no prescription
    la viagra generica funciona
    viagra no script
    werking viagra pillen

  • IsaacBom


    Comment Link Wednesday, 13 December 2017 11:05

    generic viagra 24h
    viagra no script
    price of viagra in south africa
    viagra no prescription
    illegal buy viagra australia

  • free casino slot games with bonus rounds

    free casino slot games with bonus rounds

    Comment Link Wednesday, 13 December 2017 02:17

    casino games free
    free online casino games
    casino slot games
    online casino games

  • RichardPax


    Comment Link Wednesday, 13 December 2017 01:02

    what is the new price of viagra in canada
    viagra no prescription
    what age do you have to be to get viagra
    viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland
    el mejor viagra generico

  • Roberthaf


    Comment Link Wednesday, 13 December 2017 00:57

    sildenafil 5 mg
    viagra no prescription
    pharmacy price viagra
    viagra no prescription
    best online viagra australia

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated. HTML code is not allowed.

back to top