EGA Members Begin Talks On Critical Mass, Free-Rider Issue

Members of the World Trade Organization plurilateral Environmental Goods Agreement (EGA) at their last round of negotiations began discussions on what should be done if trade among parties to the agreement dips below a “critical mass."

A source in Geneva as well as a source familiar with the negotiations told Inside U.S. Trade that members have not agreed on what percentage of world trade in products covered by the EGA must occur for the so-called critical mass to exist, but members most likely will coalesce around measures similar to those decided on in the Information Technology Agreement (ITA) expansion deal struck in December 2015.

The ITA commits members to hold discussions if the membership of the plurilateral agreement no longer represents a critical mass, defined in the Dec. 16 ITA ministerial declaration as "approximately 90 percent" of trade in the goods covered by that agreement.

Maintaining a level of trade above the critical mass threshold is considered crucial to the success of the EGA -- and plurilateral agreements in general -- because the tariff cuts made by participants will be extended to all WTO members on a most favored nation basis. If trade dips below the agreed-upon threshold, WTO members who do not participate but are major exporters of the covered goods could reap the benefits of the deal without having to lower their own tariffs. This is known as the "free rider" problem.

The Geneva source said the threshold would likely fall around 80 or 90 percent, but held open the possibility that it could be lower given the fact that discussions continue on what goods ultimately will make the final tariff-cutting list.

That source said there is little appetite among EGA members for a proposal that would allow them to withdraw or “snapback” their tariff reductions if the trade threshold is not met, and that such a proposal would raise legal and logistical questions. China's threshold proposal in the ITA expansion talks was characterized by critics as allowing members to “snapback” their tariffs, although the final ITA language did not differ substantially from China's proposal.

The Geneva source said legally there is no precedent for increasing tariff rates after members have bound them to zero in a WTO agreement. Logistically, the source said, no mechanism or procedure exists for members to reintroduce tariffs that have been eliminated, and introducing one in the EGA is unlikely.

But overall, the Geneva source argued that the critical mass issue is unlikely to arise in practice once the deal is finalized because WTO members will be keen to join the agreement, which lowers the chances of trade dropping below the critical mass threshold. EGA negotiators are aiming to conclude negotiations in 2016.

Last modified onThursday, 12 May 2016 15:51
  • Rate this item
    (0 votes)
  • Published in Updates
  • Read 22504 times

2441 comments

  • online casinos

    online casinos

    Comment Link Thursday, 14 December 2017 17:37

    free casino games download
    online casino no deposit
    casino free games
    casino slot games

  • RobertAnity

    RobertAnity

    Comment Link Thursday, 14 December 2017 14:55

    viagra + where to buy + .au
    viagra without prescription
    cheap sildenafil uk
    viagra without prescription
    valor viagra 50mg
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    buying viagra on the high street
    viagra no script
    generic viagra cheapest price

  • KennethshugH

    KennethshugH

    Comment Link Thursday, 14 December 2017 03:33

    buy viagra south africa online
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    donde puedo comprar viagra en uruguay
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    viagra vs cialis cheaper
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    buy viagra and cialis online
    viagra no prescription
    buy viagra online australia

  • Thomasspusy

    Thomasspusy

    Comment Link Thursday, 14 December 2017 01:23

    when does viagra become generic
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    100mg viagra vs 20mg levitra
    viagra without prescription
    where can i buy viagra in nyc
    viagra without prescription
    viagra tablets 100 mg x 4
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    cheap online viagra no prescription

  • Thomasvor

    Thomasvor

    Comment Link Thursday, 14 December 2017 00:27

    canadian pharmacy generic viagra no prescription
    viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland
    online pharmacy viagra
    viagra no script
    can i cut my viagra pill in half

  • JosephHox

    JosephHox

    Comment Link Wednesday, 13 December 2017 22:45

    levitra viagra together
    viagra without prescription
    cheap viagra soft
    viagra ohne rezept aus deutschland
    best place buy sildenafil

  • KatrinaMaw

    KatrinaMaw

    Comment Link Wednesday, 13 December 2017 17:00

    cash advance loans
    pay day loans
    payday loan online
    payday loans online

  • LarryBandy

    LarryBandy

    Comment Link Wednesday, 13 December 2017 16:40

    viagra btmg
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    sildenafil nombres genericos
    viagra without a doctor prescription
    when will viagra go generic in us

  • slot casino

    slot casino

    Comment Link Wednesday, 13 December 2017 16:27

    online casino
    usa online casinos
    usa online casinos
    online casinos

  • Andrewwax

    Andrewwax

    Comment Link Wednesday, 13 December 2017 16:24

    viagra cheap paypal
    viagra no prescription
    quanto costa il viagra generico in farmacia
    viagra no script
    buy herbal viagra in ireland

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated. HTML code is not allowed.

back to top