How Sitharaman Served Up India Instead of Using WTO High Table to Block US Agenda

Birak Patnaik

For those from a generation unfamiliar with the political cult classic, The Ugly American, the conduct of the United States Trade Representative, Michael Froman at the World Trade Organisation Nairobi Ministerial, would have served as a good introduction.

Even before he had boarded the plane to Nairobi, Froman had most negotiators from the developing countries, gathered for the talks in the Kenyatta Convention Centre, seething with anger with his op-ed in the Financial Times, ‘Time to be honest, we are at the end of the line on Doha’.

Arguing that “…Doha was designed in a different era, for a different era, and much has changed since”, Froman called for a different architecture at the WTO and an end to the Doha round, with clear indications that the US would block any re-affirmation of the Doha Round in the ministerial declaration. Doha negotiations, in Froman’s words, “remain deadlocked. After 14 years, including the past two years of intensified engagement, there is no light at the end of the tunnel”.

What Froman omitted from his op-ed, and his subsequent statement along similar lines to the ministerial plenary, is that the US and the EU have been the principal reason for this deadlock for the past 14 years, as they have not conceded to a wide range of proposals put forth by developing countries. On the contrary, the US has aggressively blocked various proposals, even in the last two years of intensified engagement, when it gave short shrift to the proposal of the G-33 on the public stockholding issue or on the Special Safeguard Mechanisms.

As Chakravarthi Raghavan, the wise old wizard of trade negotiations who has been covering them since 1949, put it to me, the US/EU arguments to abandon Doha because of the deadlock reminded him of the story of a son convicted for murdering his parents to get at their property who asks the court for leniency on the grounds that he was an orphan!

The reference price farce

To get a sense of how outrageous Froman’s claims are, one only has to look at the manner the US has dealt with the public stockholding issue. The external reference price to calculate food subsidies was set back in 1986-88 and has remain unchanged since then, even though food prices have gone up almost 500% since then. The implication of this is simple. The subsidy calculations for India and other developing countries get hugely inflated because the base year is so low, even though in reality they are much smaller.

If the same calculation was used to estimate US subsidies for maize farmers for 2014, the $6 billion subsidy will show up as $32 billion. As it happens, the US and EU – like many other developed countries – are exempt from having to make these calculations and much of their subsidies get protected under the Green Box. This is unlike the subsidies of most of developing countries who did not notify them when the Agreement on Agriculture was negotiated in 1995, and are therefore happy to continue with this hypocrisy. A simple updating of the external reference price from 1986-88 to current prices, as demanded by developing countries led by India has been blocked in Geneva for the last two years. So much for the times having changed.

The proposals for giving developing countries the same benefits of raising tariffs to protect domestic producers which all developed countries enjoy, under the Special Safeguard Mechanism, has met with a similar intransigence on part of the developed countries.

Sitharaman’s crocodile tears

If Froman left Nairobi after giving chutzpah a bad name, India’s commerce minister, Nirmala Sitharaman gave the world a good illustration of crocodile tears, with her closing plenary statement expressing “disappointment” at the DDA not being re-affirmed in the ministerial declaration.

She was at the centre of the negotiations and walked away with little more than assurances of pious intent, after conceding to the core US demand to drop the re-affirmation of the Doha Development Agenda (DDA) from the ministerial declaration.

As it reads now, the declaration reaffirms the Doha issues, which are central to the concerns of developing countries, but with no mention of the DDA. This was a clear red line for India as Doha was not merely a set of issues but more of a set of negotiating principles and a framework for taking the issues forward. The absence of the DDA framework will make it harder for the Indian negotiators in Geneva to drive a hard bargain on export competition, market access, public stockholding or the Special Safeguard Mechanism.

The Nairobi declaration reaffirms the Doha issues, which are central to the concerns of developing countries, but with no mention of the DDA. This breaches a clear red line for India as Doha was not merely a set of issues but more of a set of negotiating principles and a framework for taking the issues forward.

The US managed to breach yet another red line of the Indian negotiators with an explicit mention of “new issues” in the ministerial declaration. These are issues that could have been taken up only after all the issues in the DDA had been satisfactorily resolved, but can now be taken up anytime if agreed to by all members. Since decision-making in the WTO is consensus based, India and other developing countries can still block those issues from being taken up, but it’s easy to see that the US/EU have a new bargaining chip, and that progress on the Doha issues is likely to get pegged to the advance in negotiations on the “new issues”. Most of the new issues benefit developed countries and multinational corporations.

India and the developing countries did well to not allow a clear victory to the rich countries or their corporations in the language of the ministerial text by leaving the door open to the blocking of “new issues”. But it will be an uphill battle hereon.

No gains for India, only likely losses

All told, the truth is that there is little that India could extract by way of concessions, the spirited defence in Parliament of its commerce minister notwithstanding. There is just a commitment to “engage constructively to make all concerted efforts to agree to adopt a permanent solution on the issue of public stockholding for food security purposes”. In plainspeak, India will keep pushing the issue in Geneva, as it has for the past two years, and the US/EU and other developed countries are likely to continue blocking it. Since India already enjoys a peace clause – the subsidised purchases of food it makes for its PDS/Right to Food programme will not be challenged by other countries provided they avoid distorting global trade or affecting the food security of others – this is just a clarion call for business as usual.

Similarly on the SSM, we got more pious intent, “to pursue negotiations on an SSM for developing country members in dedicated sessions of the Committee on Agriculture in Special Session (“CoA SS”)”. In other words, it’s a concrete commitment to have meetings to decide on more meetings with every constructive proposal of the developing world likely to be rejected by the rich countries in those meetings. Business as usual again.

The only major gain that India made in Nairobi was perhaps to keep the US/EU from denying what it calls “emerging economies” (read: BRICS) the benefits of special and differentiated treatment that is now available to all developing countries. It was a specious argument on the part of the US in any case because by any objective standards, India cannot be shown to have graduated out of these benefits as a country that fares worse than 11 Least Developed Countries (LDCs) in the multidimensional poverty index, and worse than 22 LDCs in the number of people on the edge of poverty. India, with 195 million undernourished people (as compared to 186 million in all the 47 LDCs put together), ranks worse than 14 LDCs in the Global hunger Index. Even so, it was a small but significant victory.

As for India, it lost the plot on the penultimate day, when it broke ranks with the G-90 and the rest of the developing countries for a seat at the table with the US, EU, China and Brazil (the G-5), to negotiate the final texts. Despite having the finest negotiators at the WTO in Geneva that any country could hope for, India fell short when the time came for a political call to be taken. And in doing so, also lost many allies who had stood by it through this period. Despite the weak assertions of the commerce minister on her “disappointment” at the declaration not reaffirming the DDA, truth be told, she lost the nerve to block the declaration. Having got a place on the high table, Nirmala Sitharaman ended up putting India on the menu instead.

The “constructive ambiguity” of the text that has emerged from Nairobi will ensure that the legal wrangling on its interpretations will continue in Geneva long after the ink on the declaration has dried out.

And for now, The Ugly American, seems to have prevailed.

Biraj Patnaik is the Principal Adviser in the Office of the Supreme Court commissioners on the Right to Food. The views expressed in this article are personal.

http://thewire.in/2015/12/25/the-ugly-american-and-compliant-indian-17894/

  • Rate this item
    (0 votes)
  • Published in Updates
  • Read 13447 times

507 comments

  • Lewisref

    Lewisref

    Comment Link Sunday, 01 April 2018 22:05

    buy cialis professional online
    buy cialis online
    ac uk buy cialis
    cialis
    cialis pills women
    canadian cialis
    buy cialis mississauga
    cialis usa
    buy generic cialis canada

  • fast quick loans online

    fast quick loans online

    Comment Link Sunday, 01 April 2018 20:39

    loans online application
    online payday loans tx
    payday loans online bad credit
    trusted payday loans online

  • car insurance quotes comparison online

    car insurance quotes comparison online

    Comment Link Saturday, 31 March 2018 17:11

    cheap auto insurance quotes california
    auto insurance quotes for individuals
    cheap auto insurance online
    cheap car insurance companies

  • car insurance comparison

    car insurance comparison

    Comment Link Saturday, 31 March 2018 10:36

    auto insurance quotes comparison online
    auto insurance quotes
    cheap car insurance quotes
    cheap auto insurance quotes

  • cheap car insurance calculator

    cheap car insurance calculator

    Comment Link Saturday, 31 March 2018 01:05

    auto insurance policy
    car insurance requirements
    cheap auto insurance quotes california
    car insurance

  • cheap car insurance quotes

    cheap car insurance quotes

    Comment Link Friday, 30 March 2018 19:17

    cheap car insurance quotes
    auto insurance quotes geico
    car insurance quotes
    car insurance companies

  • langauth

    langauth

    Comment Link Friday, 30 March 2018 11:29

    generic cialis
    cialis cost
    https://besiktasboschservis.com/ - online cialis OK’

  • AlyonaTot

    AlyonaTot

    Comment Link Friday, 30 March 2018 07:04

    can buy viagra auckland|viagra list price|viagra per farmaco di signore|viagra safe online|efectos viagra en el deport|grapefruit viagra|viagra men women buy|viagra torrinomedic|viagra nhs uk|cheap female viagra sale uk|viagra cialis australia|bringing viagra mexico canada|il costo di 10 mg viagra|viagra flugzeug mitnehmen|usa viagra cheap|generic viagra nz|click here viagra now|generic viagra propecia|viagra professional dosage|best generic viagra seller|viagra herbario en farmacia|can viagra cause leg pain|click here cheap pill viagra|viagra price in inr|buy viagra overnight online|pregnancy and viagra|pfizer viagra blue pill|viagra black vomit|visit our site viagra dosage|best buy 100mg viagra tablets|buy no australia viagra|online shopping viagra online|viagra generika per nachnahme|viagra wirkstoffmenge|le viagra levitr|viagra increase|feeling after take viagra|purchase cialis and viagra|viagra canadian scam|generic viagra uk cheapest|will 100mg of viagra work|usefull link order viagra usa|viagra generica onlin|enter site viagra super active|viagra 100 mg caplin piont|online viagra u can|quel est le rle du viagra|pldora genrica de viagra|viagra dosage recomendation|viagra generico doctor simi|viagra ipertensione arteriosa|free cialis viagra samples|viagra prescriptions without|we choice buy viagra in mexico|uk buy viagra|click here buy internet viagra|viagra canada teva|muestra de viagra fedex|price of viagra 50 mg tab|prix viagra 50 mg pfizer|compre ventas viagra baratas|wow look it buy viagra pill|buy dapoxetine viagra online|generic canada viagra|achat cialis ou viagra|price viagra per pill|buy viagra tabs|africa south viagra|priligy and viagra together|cmo usar viagra|si perdoret viagra|click now viagra pfizer|viagra mg price|visit our site use viagra|uk viagra online paypal|viagra sin receta farmacia|la viagra generica funciona|i recommend viagra cheap|vipps pharmacy viagra|viagra store in chennai|tips buying viagra online|viagra canada com review|in uk place viagra to best|viagra bruxelles|viagra best ejaculation pills|mercury drugstore viagra|viagra price kuala lumpur|fake viagra ingredients|buy viagra discount online|what dosage viagra do i need|preisvergleich viagra 12|viagra online paypal andorra|buy viagra in ahmedabad|tabs viagra canada|canadian cheap generic viagra|buy unprescribed viagra|viagra pfizer ohne rezept|prices viagra|viagra in farmacia costo|india viagra generic|viagra generico santiago|viagra contraindicaciones|only for you viagra dosage|we use it viagra for women|viagra 20mg cipla|generic viagra medicine|cialis viagra milano|there any generic viagra|cvs pharmacy viagra prices|generic viagra from cipla|generic viagra vs professional|vente viagra naturel|viagra rezeptfrei paypa|comprare viagra e cialis|canadian viagra 50mg|find cheap price viagra|is viagra prescription free|sildenafil viagra tablets|commande viagra cialis|sale online viagra ie|we recommend viagra tablets|buy viagra online for women|preisvergleich viagra versan|viagra with dapoxetine review|viagra over counter california|wow look it samples of viagra|viagra supplements|order no viagra online|order viagra jelly overnight|sales on viagra|lowest viagra prices in canada|kaufen viagra|buy generic viagra jelly uk|viagra cialis autres|viagra napoli|como conseguir viagra en chile|viagra and male orgazum|order generic ca viagra|timing to take viagra|viagra overnight fedex cheap|stiff competition for viagra|only now generic viagra canada|order non generic viagra soft|comrpar viagra madrid|we like it viagra india|shall i take viagra medicine|click here viagra offical site|uk viagra cheapest|viagra aus polen kaufen|120 mg viagra|acheter du viagra lyon|cheap viagra force|viagraverkauf deutschland|viagra soft 2 day delivery|we like it cialis new viagra|cost of viagra levitra cialis|tomar viagra yahoo|viagra buyers|cialis or viagra|viagra 4 hour warning|wo kann man viagra bestelle|compra viagrapills|price for 100mg viagra tablets|australia viagra buy|generic viagra brands in india|black market viagra in canada|bene viagra o levitra|viagra samples free how to get|wholesale viagra china|tricare copay viagra|viagra for sale denver|viagra first time|comprare il viagra in india|buy tadalafil viagra|link for you viagra samples|precio del viagra en panam|viagra vent|one viagra tablets price|viagra cinese|i use it order viagra today|buying cheapest viagra|viagra female in uk|generico do viagra dosagem|viagra p apotek|how much 1 viagra tablet costs|viagra fencing australia|costo del viagra en lima|generisches viagra fr frau|per il viagra ci vuole ricetta|best viagra deals|generic viagra england|discount viagra us|viagra azul|just try cheap viagra pill|25 mg generic viagra|i recommend how to buy viagra|achat viagra espagne|kjope viagra online|viagra reaction time|with compare viagra viagra|prescription viagra france|viagra genrico de canad|cheap viagra a|reasons viagra might not work|preis viagra rezeptfrei|generika viagra billig|precio viagra farmacias chile|come comprare il canada viagra|viagra sleep problems|potenzmittel viagra usw|viagra for woman|viagra 100mg price costco|erboristeria viagra femminile|cheap viagra 25mg|viagra 100mg angebot|comprare viagra lin|viagra en pharmacie a paris|jama viagra|blindness and viagra|viagra billig piller|viagra dure|el viagra y la hipertension|viagra soft results forum|cheapest viagra and regalis|genuine viagra prices|viagra20 mg ohne rezept|visit web site viagra aus usa|viagra how often can one take|coste de viagra en farmacias|il viagra danneggia ludit|viagra in usa online|most effective herbal viagra|acquisto viagra austria|viagra zealand|usefull link price viagra|find cheap viagra online|brand viagra cheap 50|buy viagra in new delhi|viagra super bestellen|viagra ou cialis doctissimo|only for you viagra canadian|dosis viagra efectos|viagra online best pharmacy|click here 50mg viagra|viagra levitra ciali|only today viagra canada cheap|can i get viagra if im young|viagra zantac|como se faz viagra de mandioca|buy viagra onlines

    cheap viagra,online viagra,viagra online,viagra cheap,buy viagra,viagra,viagra,viagra cheap,buy viagra,buy viagra online
    cheap viagra,online viagra,viagra online,viagra cheap,buy viagra,viagra,viagra,viagra cheap,buy viagra,buy viagra online

    can buy viagra auckland|viagra list price|viagra per farmaco di signore|viagra safe online|efectos viagra en el deport|grapefruit viagra|viagra men women buy|viagra torrinomedic|viagra nhs uk|cheap female viagra sale uk|viagra cialis australia|bringing viagra mexico canada|il costo di 10 mg viagra|viagra flugzeug mitnehmen|usa viagra cheap|generic viagra nz|click here viagra now|generic viagra propecia|viagra professional dosage|best generic viagra seller|viagra herbario en farmacia|can viagra cause leg pain|click here cheap pill viagra|viagra price in inr|buy viagra overnight online|pregnancy and viagra|pfizer viagra blue pill|viagra black vomit|visit our site viagra dosage|best buy 100mg viagra tablets|buy no australia viagra|online shopping viagra online|viagra generika per nachnahme|viagra wirkstoffmenge|le viagra levitr|viagra increase|feeling after take viagra|purchase cialis and viagra|viagra canadian scam|generic viagra uk cheapest|will 100mg of viagra work|usefull link order viagra usa|viagra generica onlin|enter site viagra super active|viagra 100 mg caplin piont|online viagra u can|quel est le rle du viagra|pldora genrica de viagra|viagra dosage recomendation|viagra generico doctor simi|viagra ipertensione arteriosa|free cialis viagra samples|viagra prescriptions without|we choice buy viagra in mexico|uk buy viagra|click here buy internet viagra|viagra canada teva|muestra de viagra fedex|price of viagra 50 mg tab|prix viagra 50 mg pfizer|compre ventas viagra baratas|wow look it buy viagra pill|buy dapoxetine viagra online|generic canada viagra|achat cialis ou viagra|price viagra per pill|buy viagra tabs|africa south viagra|priligy and viagra together|cmo usar viagra|si perdoret viagra|click now viagra pfizer|viagra mg price|visit our site use viagra|uk viagra online paypal|viagra sin receta farmacia|la viagra generica funciona|i recommend viagra cheap|vipps pharmacy viagra|viagra store in chennai|tips buying viagra online|viagra canada com review|in uk place viagra to best|viagra bruxelles|viagra best ejaculation pills|mercury drugstore viagra|viagra price kuala lumpur|fake viagra ingredients|buy viagra discount online|what dosage viagra do i need|preisvergleich viagra 12|viagra online paypal andorra|buy viagra in ahmedabad|tabs viagra canada|canadian cheap generic viagra|buy unprescribed viagra|viagra pfizer ohne rezept|prices viagra|viagra in farmacia costo|india viagra generic|viagra generico santiago|viagra contraindicaciones|only for you viagra dosage|we use it viagra for women|viagra 20mg cipla|generic viagra medicine|cialis viagra milano|there any generic viagra|cvs pharmacy viagra prices|generic viagra from cipla|generic viagra vs professional|vente viagra naturel|viagra rezeptfrei paypa|comprare viagra e cialis|canadian viagra 50mg|find cheap price viagra|is viagra prescription free|sildenafil viagra tablets|commande viagra cialis|sale online viagra ie|we recommend viagra tablets|buy viagra online for women|preisvergleich viagra versan|viagra with dapoxetine review|viagra over counter california|wow look it samples of viagra|viagra supplements|order no viagra online|order viagra jelly overnight|sales on viagra|lowest viagra prices in canada|kaufen viagra|buy generic viagra jelly uk|viagra cialis autres|viagra napoli|como conseguir viagra en chile|viagra and male orgazum|order generic ca viagra|timing to take viagra|viagra overnight fedex cheap|stiff competition for viagra|only now generic viagra canada|order non generic viagra soft|comrpar viagra madrid|we like it viagra india|shall i take viagra medicine|click here viagra offical site|uk viagra cheapest|viagra aus polen kaufen|120 mg viagra|acheter du viagra lyon|cheap viagra force|viagraverkauf deutschland|viagra soft 2 day delivery|we like it cialis new viagra|cost of viagra levitra cialis|tomar viagra yahoo|viagra buyers|cialis or viagra|viagra 4 hour warning|wo kann man viagra bestelle|compra viagrapills|price for 100mg viagra tablets|australia viagra buy|generic viagra brands in india|black market viagra in canada|bene viagra o levitra|viagra samples free how to get|wholesale viagra china|tricare copay viagra|viagra for sale denver|viagra first time|comprare il viagra in india|buy tadalafil viagra|link for you viagra samples|precio del viagra en panam|viagra vent|one viagra tablets price|viagra cinese|i use it order viagra today|buying cheapest viagra|viagra female in uk|generico do viagra dosagem|viagra p apotek|how much 1 viagra tablet costs|viagra fencing australia|costo del viagra en lima|generisches viagra fr frau|per il viagra ci vuole ricetta|best viagra deals|generic viagra england|discount viagra us|viagra azul|just try cheap viagra pill|25 mg generic viagra|i recommend how to buy viagra|achat viagra espagne|kjope viagra online|viagra reaction time|with compare viagra viagra|prescription viagra france|viagra genrico de canad|cheap viagra a|reasons viagra might not work|preis viagra rezeptfrei|generika viagra billig|precio viagra farmacias chile|come comprare il canada viagra|viagra sleep problems|potenzmittel viagra usw|viagra for woman|viagra 100mg price costco|erboristeria viagra femminile|cheap viagra 25mg|viagra 100mg angebot|comprare viagra lin|viagra en pharmacie a paris|jama viagra|blindness and viagra|viagra billig piller|viagra dure|el viagra y la hipertension|viagra soft results forum|cheapest viagra and regalis|genuine viagra prices|viagra20 mg ohne rezept|visit web site viagra aus usa|viagra how often can one take|coste de viagra en farmacias|il viagra danneggia ludit|viagra in usa online|most effective herbal viagra|acquisto viagra austria|viagra zealand|usefull link price viagra|find cheap viagra online|brand viagra cheap 50|buy viagra in new delhi|viagra super bestellen|viagra ou cialis doctissimo|only for you viagra canadian|dosis viagra efectos|viagra online best pharmacy|click here 50mg viagra|viagra levitra ciali|only today viagra canada cheap|can i get viagra if im young|viagra zantac|como se faz viagra de mandioca|buy viagra onlines

  • Hnbantig

    Hnbantig

    Comment Link Friday, 30 March 2018 02:56

    best viagra price
    viagra buy
    viagra effects on women
    cheap viagra OK’

  • free casino games and poker

    free casino games and poker

    Comment Link Wednesday, 28 March 2018 17:57

    casinos online
    casinos online
    casino online gambling
    casino g

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated. HTML code is not allowed.

back to top