End of The Road - Economic & Political Weekly

Economic & Political Weekly: December 5, 2015

The 14-year-long tortured Doha Round may be effectively buried in Nairobi this month.

The run-up to the 10th ministerial meeting of the World Trade Organization (WTO) in Nairobi later this month has been anything but constructive. Kenya’s capital will see a battle that will decide whether the WTO can provide a few minimally credible developmental outcomes for its large membership of developing and the poorest countries. More likely, to suit the interests of the advanced countries the Doha Develop- ment Agenda (DDA) will be all but buried.

Attempts to finalise the Nairobi ministerial statement are currently mired in unbridgeable differences on several points, especially the future of the unresolved issues of the long- running DDA. A questionable package of outcomes that sidesteps the core issue of trade distorting domestic subsidies in agriculture is being pursued to suit only one country, the United States (US). At the heart of the divide is that the Triad of the three largest advanced economies—the US, European Union (EU) and Japan—seems determined to empty the Doha Round of all content. In 2001, immediately after the 9/11 terrorist attacks, the Triad launched the DDA negotiations in the face of intense opposition from developing countries. To make the round acceptable, the group agreed to address the fundamental inequi- ties of global trade arising from the previous Uruguay Round agreement. After 14 years of spasmodic negotiations, the Triad and some other developed countries now feel that the Doha Round is a costly undertaking because of the reforms that would be required in agriculture, especially for the US. Washington has passed a new farm bill that takes farm support to well beyond the Doha ceiling of $14.5 billion. Moreover, the Triad has already managed to pocket a binding WTO trade facilitation agreement (TFA) without having to pay anything for it. The TFA is the jewel in the crown that it fought so hard to retain in the DDA negotiations after it was initially stamped out by the developing countries at the Cancun ministerial meeting in 2003.

Against this backdrop, a small package of deliverables on not very important issues that would be agreed to in Nairobi was forced on the larger membership through a top-down approach. The Triad, along with Australia, Canada and Brazil, among others, has also ruled out any agreement in Nairobi on two major de- mands of the G-33 group of developing countries. The G-33 group, which includes Indonesia, India, China, Kenya and 43 other

developing countries, has all along demanded a special safeguard mechanism (SSM) and a permanent solution for public stockholding programmes of food security for resource-poor farmers in the developing countries. To worsen matters, the developing coun- tries will be asked to make a trade-off between continuation of the DDA in some form and the continuation of decades-long nego- tiating approaches, such as special and differential treatment and less-than-full reciprocity. If the latter were to be given up, India, China and South Africa will have to take almost identical commit- ments as the advanced economies to reduce agricultural tariffs to applied levels and subsidies; the US will otherwise not agree to return to the table and negotiate on agriculture.

In short, when trade ministers from the developing world congregate at Nairobi they will be fighting with their backs to the wall to preserve the Doha Round in its original form which they initially opposed but then into which they invested so much of their negotiating capital. The moot issue is, why many developing countries, particularly India, allowed things to come to such a pass, knowing well that losing leverage in a mercantile negotiating framework can have costly consequences. Since their failure to ram through a package at the Cancun ministerial meeting in 2003, the US and other members of the Triad have constantly weighed their gains in a multilateral round with benefits from bilateral/regional free trade agreements (FTAs). At the WTO, even as these countries agreed on the July

2004 framework agreement, the 2005 Hong Kong ministerial declaration, and the 2013 Bali agreement,   all negotiated to reach a comprehensive   package, they were simultaneously going ahead with concluding FTAs. But the turning point in the Doha Round negotiations was in 2008. That was the year when the US decided to set its sights on the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) Agreement because at the TPP it would not have to address its trade-distorting agricultural subsidies.

Despite these changes occurring outside the WTO, the devel- oping countries went on offering concessions at Geneva in the hope that they would secure gains in other areas. As late as

2013, the Triad, led by the US, forced the TFA on the developing countries which did not ask for, nor were given, anything in return. At Bali in 2013, India agreed to the TFA in return for a weak and economically insignificant undertaking on public stockholding programmes for food security. Then, Prime Minister Narendra Modi had a chance to reverse that outcome but went ahead and agreed during a visit to the US in September 2014 to sign on to the TFA without securing a cast iron agreement on public stockholding programmes for food security.

In short, the developing world now finds that it has surrendered much of the leverage it had and will be unable to reverse things at Nairobi, except by naming and shaming the US for having effectively killed the Doha Round. If India and other developing countries fail to do even that, they would forgo whatever limited chance they have of securing a permanent solution for public stockholding programmes for food security, the SSM, and a credible result on cotton.

Last modified onMonday, 07 December 2015 14:55
  • Rate this item
    (0 votes)
  • Published in Opinions
  • Read 6788 times


  • Buy Custom Essays

    Buy Custom Essays

    Comment Link Friday, 16 February 2018 20:10

    can you do my homework homework homework homework for me

  • JamesFlami


    Comment Link Friday, 16 February 2018 18:55

    cash advance loan loans online no credit check advance cash payday loan payday advance loan essay prompts research essay write essay help with homework online chat payday loan payday loan companies payday advance no credit check money loan free porn shows pussy webcam webcam masturbation webcam dildo buy an essay buy essay online essay online do my college algebra write a paper college level essay writing term paper research paper thesis

  • best auto insurance

    best auto insurance

    Comment Link Friday, 16 February 2018 18:21

    direct general auto insurance quote car insurance renewal insurance auto auto insurance in florida

  • autoinsurance


    Comment Link Friday, 16 February 2018 17:15

    aig auto insurance cheapest car insurance cheapest car insurance cheap full coverage auto insurance

  • Fastest Payday Loan

    Fastest Payday Loan

    Comment Link Friday, 16 February 2018 15:34

    extended payday loans what is a bank loan emergency loans low interest personal loans

  • Payday Loans Online

    Payday Loans Online

    Comment Link Friday, 16 February 2018 15:00

    housing loans web loan web loan web loan

  • JamesFlami


    Comment Link Friday, 16 February 2018 14:56

    get your homework done online buy term papers online research writing research writing research essay writing a prospectus for a research paper person doing homework research essay porn cams hot porno show live porn cam live porn cams free erotic chat free sex webcam chat free sex webcam chat adult chat room porn cams webcams porn nude chats porn webcams school papers research papers online homework solutions essay writer webcam masturbation adult cam live sex chat live sex chat online payday loans direct lenders online payday loans direct lenders online payday loans direct lenders online payday loans direct lenders scholarship essay argumentative essay english homework help online essay corrector best payday loan online best payday loan best payday loans best payday loan

  • Online Homework

    Online Homework

    Comment Link Friday, 16 February 2018 14:47

    essay writing formula essays scholarship essays buy essay services

  • insurance auto

    insurance auto

    Comment Link Friday, 16 February 2018 14:31

    auto ins cheap car insurance in alabama the cheapest car insurance available cheapest car insurance available

  • aarp car insurance

    aarp car insurance

    Comment Link Friday, 16 February 2018 14:22

    state farm auto insurance auto insurance quotes online free auto insurance quotes best auto insurance companies

Leave a comment

Make sure you enter the (*) required information where indicated. HTML code is not allowed.

back to top